top of page

Moment Frame Design

Dec 1, 2024
9 min read

Updated: 5 days ago

Introduction

Moment frames are a vital part of structural engineering, offering a robust and flexible solution for lateral load resistance in buildings and other structures. These systems allow engineers to design efficient frameworks that balance structural integrity, cost-effectiveness, and aesthetic considerations. In this post, we’ll walk through the key aspects of moment frame design, covering the design of steel members, connections, and foundations, with an illustrative example problem using CalcBook to demonstrate a streamlined workflow.


Bolted steel beam-to-column moment connection, and the bending moment diagram of a one-bay portal frame with W14X68 columns and a W18X76 beam.


What Are Moment Frames?

Moment frames are structural systems designed to resist lateral forces—such as those caused by wind or seismic activity—by allowing controlled flexural deformation in beams and columns. Unlike braced frames or shear walls, moment frames rely on the rigid connections between members to transfer loads and resist rotation, giving them a high degree of flexibility in design and application.

Moment frames are widely used in mid-rise and high-rise buildings where open floor plans and architectural freedom are priorities. Their primary benefits include the ability to accommodate large openings and the potential for significant energy dissipation during seismic events. However, these advantages come with trade-offs: moment frames can be more expensive to construct due to the complexity of their connections and may require careful attention to deflection limits and stability.


Key Considerations

Here are the critical factors to keep in mind throughout the design process for a moment frame:


  • Geometry: The arrangement of beams, columns, and connections affects overall stability, stiffness, and load transfer. Evaluate the height, width, and spacing of members to optimize the frame’s performance.

  • Loads: Consider all relevant loads, including gravity, wind, seismic, and live loads, and their combinations. Moment frames are particularly sensitive to lateral forces and overturning moments.

  • Material Properties: Understand the properties of the steel and concrete used in the design. High-strength materials can reduce member sizes but may lead to increased connection demands.

  • Member Design: Check beams and columns for flexural, shear, and axial capacity, including combined loading per AISC 360 requirements. Ensure members meet strength and serviceability criteria.

  • Connection Design: Rigid connections are the cornerstone of moment frames. Check the beam flange forces on the column flange and web, and the column panel zone shear, per AISC 360 Section J10.

  • Foundation Design: Spread footings must resist both axial and lateral loads. Ensure they are designed for bearing pressure, sliding, overturning, one-way shear, two-way shear, and flexure per ACI 318, considering load combinations and eccentricity.



Example Problem


The example problem below is divided into three sections: Member Design, Connection Design, and Foundation Design (Solved with CalcBook) Part 1: Member Design Problem Statement:

Example problem: moment frame 12 ft tall and 14 ft wide with W14x68 columns and a W18x76 beam (A992), pinned bases, DL = 0.35 k/ft, LL = 0.45 k/ft and Ex = 15 kips.

Applied Loading:

Frame load cases: dead load 0.35 k/ft and live load 0.45 k/ft on the W18X76 beam, and a 15 kip earthquake load at the top of the frame.

Analysis Results:

Analysis results for 1.2D + 1.0E + 1.0L: column P 20.5 kips, M 97.4 k-ft, V 8.1 kips; beam P 8.1 kips, M 97.6 k-ft, V 19.6 kips; nominal base reactions PDL 3.8 k, PLL 3.2 k, PEQ 12.86 k (plus or minus) and VEQ 7.51 k, with the moment diagram and base reactions.

Column Design (W14X68)

The column forces from the 1.2D + 1.0E + 1.0L analysis are Pu = 20.5 kips, Mu = 97.4 kip-ft and Vu = 8.1 kips. They are entered in CalcBook's steel member module as factored design loads (Load Combinations: None), with a 12 ft unbraced length about both axes, K = 1.0, Lb = 12 ft and Cb = 1.0.

Weak-axis buckling governs the column: Ly/ry = 144 in. / 2.46 in. = 58.5. In the plane of this pinned-base frame the effective length factor is about 1.8 (AISC alignment chart, sway frame), but KxLx/rx = 1.82 × 144 in. / 6.01 in. = 43.6 is still below 58.5, so the axial strength is the same either way.

φPn = 700.54 kips, φMnx = 405.37 kip-ft and φVn = 174.30 kips


CalcBook design summary for the W14X68 column: compression 20.50 vs 700.54 kips (0.03), strong-axis flexure 97.40 vs 405.37 kip-ft (0.24), shear 8.10 vs 174.30 kips (0.05) and combined loading 0.25, all OK.

Pr/Pc = 20.5 / 700.54 = 0.029 < 0.2, so AISC Equation H1-1b applies:

Pr/(2Pc) + Mrx/Mcx = 20.5 / (2 × 700.54) + 97.4 / 405.37 = 0.25 ≤ 1.0, OK


CalcBook show-your-work for column combined loading: Pr/Pc = 0.029 < 0.2, so AISC Eq. H1-1b gives 20.5/(2 x 700.54) + 97.4/405.37 = 0.25.

Beam Design (W18X76)

The beam carries Pu = 8.1 kips (compression), Mu = 97.6 kip-ft and Vu = 19.6 kips, with a 14 ft unbraced length (K = 1.0, Lb = 14 ft, Cb = 1.0):

φPn = 741.23 kips, φMnx = 550.22 kip-ft and φVn = 232.05 kips


CalcBook design summary for the W18X76 beam: compression 8.10 vs 741.23 kips (0.01), strong-axis flexure 97.60 vs 550.22 kip-ft (0.18), shear 19.60 vs 232.05 kips (0.08) and combined loading 0.18, all OK.

Pr/Pc = 0.011 < 0.2, so Equation H1-1b applies again:

8.1 / (2 × 741.23) + 97.6 / 550.22 = 0.18 ≤ 1.0, OK


CalcBook show-your-work for beam combined loading: Pr/Pc = 0.011 < 0.2, so AISC Eq. H1-1b gives 8.1/(2 x 741.23) + 97.6/550.22 = 0.18.




Part 2: Connection Design

Problem Statement:

Example problem: directly welded flange moment connection checked to AISC 360 Section J10 for flange local bending, web local yielding, web local crippling, web sidesway buckling, web compression buckling and web panel zone shear.

Calculate Loading:

Beam-to-column moment connection with beam forces Mu 97.6 k-ft, Vu 19.6 k and Pu 8.1 k and column forces Mu 97.4 k-ft, Vu 8.1 k and Pu 20.5 k; flange force (97.6 x 12)/(18.2 - 0.68) = 66.8 kips, use 67 kips; W18x76 and W14x68 section properties.

Concentrated Flange Forces (AISC 360-22 Section J10)

The 67 kip flange force is entered in CalcBook's Concentrated Flange Loads module as a factored design load (Load Combinations: None), with the column moment of 97.4 kip-ft, on a W14X68 column. The bearing length is the beam flange thickness, lb = 0.68 in., and the force acts x = 18.2 in. below the top of the column (the beam depth, where the bottom flange delivers its force). The moment reverses under seismic load, so the force is checked once in tension and once in compression.


CalcBook Flanges with Concentrated Forces inputs: tension, moment connection, braced compression flange, force on one flange only, x = 18.2 in., lb = 0.68 in., W14X68 column, Lb = 144 in., Fyf = Fyw = 50 ksi.

Tension: flange local bending (Equation J10-1) and web local yielding. Since x = 18.2 in. > d = 14 in., web local yielding uses Equation J10-2:

φRn = 0.90 × 6.25Fyftf2 = 0.90 × 6.25 × 50 ksi × (0.72 in.)2 = 145.80 kips

φRn = 1.0 × Fywtw(5k + lb) = 50 ksi × 0.415 in. × (5 × 1.31 in. + 0.68 in.) = 150.02 kips


CalcBook show-your-work for AISC J10.1 flange local bending, Rn = 6.25 x 50 ksi x (0.72 in.)^2 = 162 kips and phi Rn = 145.8 kips, and J10.2 web local yielding by Eq. J10-2, Rn = 150.02 kips.

Flange local bending: 67 / 145.80 = 0.46. Web local yielding: 67 / 150.02 = 0.45.


CalcBook summary for the 67 kip tension flange force: flange local bending 145.80 kips (D/C 0.46) and web local yielding 150.02 kips (D/C 0.45), both OK.

Compression: web local yielding is the same 150.02 kips. Since x ≥ d/2 = 7 in., web local crippling uses Equation J10-4:

φRn = 0.75 × 0.80tw2[1 + 3(lb/d)(tw/tf)1.5]√(EFywtf/tw)Qf = 0.75 × 232.47 kips = 174.35 kips

CalcBook skips web sidesway buckling (J10.4) for a moment connection, and web compression buckling (J10.5) because the force acts on one flange only.


CalcBook show-your-work for AISC J10.3 web local crippling by Eq. J10-4, Rn = 232.47 kips and phi Rn = 174.35 kips; web sidesway buckling and web compression buckling do not apply.

Web local yielding: 67 / 150.02 = 0.45. Web local crippling: 67 / 174.35 = 0.38.


CalcBook summary for the 67 kip compression flange force: web local yielding 150.02 kips (D/C 0.45) and web local crippling 174.35 kips (D/C 0.38), both OK.

Panel Zone Shear (AISC 360-22 Section J10.6)

The panel zone carries the full 67 kip flange force, since no column continues above the roof beam. With αPr = 20.5 kips ≤ 0.4Py = 392.25 kips, and panel zone deformation not included in the frame analysis, Equation J10-9 applies:

φRn = 0.90 × 0.60Fydctw = 0.90 × 0.60 × 50 ksi × 14 in. × 0.415 in. = 156.87 kips ≥ 67 kips, D/C = 0.43, OK


CalcBook show-your-work for AISC J10.6 panel zone shear: Py = 980.62 kips, alpha Pr = 20.5 kips <= 0.4Py, so Eq. J10-9 gives Rn = 174.3 kips and phi Rn = 156.87 kips.

Flange local bending governs at D/C = 0.46, and the panel zone is at 0.43, so the column needs no stiffeners or doubler plate for this flange force.





Part 3: Foundation Design

Problem Statement:

Example problem: spread footing for the frame reactions per ACI 318-19, checked for bearing pressure, sliding and overturning (ASD) and one-way shear, two-way shear and flexure (LRFD).

Loads and Design Inputs:

Frame base reactions: dead P 3.8 k and V 0.28 k, live P 3.2 k and V 0.3 k, seismic P 12.9 k downward or uplift with V 7.5 k (pinned base, no moment); soil design parameters qa = 2000 psf and qlat = 150 psf/ft with a one-third increase permitted, friction coefficient 0.25, top of footing 2 ft below grade.

Footing Inputs

The footing is 8 ft × 8 ft × 1.5 ft thick, with a 1.5 ft square pedestal 2 ft tall, 2 ft of soil above the footing, and eight No. 7 bottom bars with 3 in. cover. The soil values come from the problem statement: 2,000 psf allowable bearing and 150 psf/ft lateral bearing, both raised by one-third for seismic (2,670 psf and 200 psf/ft), and a friction coefficient of 0.25.


CalcBook spread footing inputs: 8 ft x 8 ft x 1.5 ft footing, 2 ft of soil, 1.5 ft square pedestal 2 ft tall, eight No. 7 bars with 3 in. cover, allowable bearing 2 and 2.67 ksf, lateral bearing 0.15 and 0.2 ksf/ft, friction 0.25, f'c 4,000 psi, fy 60,000 psi.

The base reactions are entered unfactored (D: P = 3.8 kips, V = 0.28 kips; L: P = 3.2 kips, V = 0.3 kips; E: V = 7.5 kips), and CalcBook adds the footing, pedestal and soil weight and runs the ASCE 7-22 ASD and LRFD combinations. The seismic axial force reverses, so the footing is run twice: with PE = +12.9 kips (downward) and with PE = -12.9 kips (uplift). The screenshots below are from the uplift run, which governs sliding and overturning.


Bearing Pressure (ASD)

D + L (ASD LC2): P = 3.8 + 3.2 + 0.68 (pedestal) + 29.22 (footing and soil) = 36.9 kips and M = (0.28 + 0.30) kips × (1.5 + 2) ft = 2.03 kip-ft, so e = 0.055 ft, well within the kern (L/6 = 1.33 ft):

qmax = P/(BL) × (1 + 6e/L) = 36.9 kips / 64 ft² × (1 + 6 × 0.055 / 8) = 0.60 ksf ≤ 2.0 ksf, D/C = 0.30


CalcBook show-your-work for bearing pressure under ASD LC2 (D + L): Ptot = 36.9 kips, Mtot = 2.03 kip-ft, e = 0.055 ft within the kern limit L/6 = 1.33 ft, and edge pressures of 0.60 and 0.55 ksf.

For total bearing with seismic, the downward run governs: 0.89 ksf under ASD LC8 (D + 0.7E) against 2.67 ksf, D/C = 0.33.


Sliding (ASD)

ASD LC10 (0.6D + 0.7E) with seismic uplift gives the least normal force and the largest shear: V = 0.6 × 0.28 + 0.7 × 7.5 = 5.42 kips and P = 11.19 kips.

Friction: Fr,fric = μP = 0.25 × 11.19 kips = 2.80 kips

Passive resistance on the footing, including the top 1 ft of soil, at 0.2 ksf/ft: Ptof = 0.2 × 2 ft = 0.40 ksf, Pbof = 0.2 × 3.5 ft = 0.70 ksf, and Fr,pass = 0.5 × (0.40 + 0.70) ksf × 1.5 ft × 8 ft = 6.60 kips

FR = 2.80 + 6.60 = 9.40 kips. With a factor of safety of 1.5, the allowable sliding resistance is 9.40 / 1.5 = 6.26 kips ≥ 5.42 kips, D/C = 0.86, OK


CalcBook show-your-work for sliding: passive resistance 6.6 kips, friction 0.25 x 11.19 kips = 2.8 kips, total 9.4 kips, and a factor of safety of 1.73 against 5.42 kips.

The one-third increase on the lateral bearing pressure decides this check, and it is taken as given in the problem statement. The soil values match IBC Table 1806.2, class 4. IBC Section 1806.1 permits the one-third increase on those presumptive values only when they are used with the alternative allowable stress design load combinations that include wind or earthquake loads. With the ASCE 7 combinations used here and 150 psf/ft, the sliding D/C would be 1.05.


Overturning (ASD)

Same combination: Mot = 5.42 kips × (1.5 + 2) ft = 18.96 kip-ft and Mr = P × L/2 = 11.19 kips × 4 ft = 44.75 kip-ft, a factor of safety of 2.36. With the 1.5 factor of safety entered in CalcBook: D/C = 18.96 / (44.75 / 1.5) = 0.64, OK


CalcBook show-your-work for overturning under ASD LC10: overturning moment 18.96 kip-ft, resisting moment 44.75 kip-ft, factor of safety 2.36.

One-Way Shear (LRFD)

d = 18 in. - 3 in. - 0.875 in. / 2 = 14.56 in. (1.21 ft), and the critical section is d from the pedestal face. In the uplift run, LRFD LC1 (1.4D) governs:

Vu1 = 0.5 × (0.75 + 0.74) ksf × 8 ft × (3.25 - 1.21) ft = 12.2 kips

With no shear reinforcement, Vc comes from ACI 318-19 Table 22.5.5.1(c), and the size effect factor λs is neglected for footings (13.2.6.2):

Vc = 8λ(ρw)1/3√f′cbd = 8 × 1.0 × (0.0034)1/3 × √4,000 psi × 96 in. × 14.56 in. = 106.71 kips, φVn = 0.75 × 106.71 = 80.03 kips, D/C = 0.15


CalcBook show-your-work for one-way shear: demand 12.2 kips at d from the pedestal face, and Vc by ACI 318-19 Table 22.5.5.1(c) = 106.71 kips, phi Vn = 80.03 kips.

The downward run raises the demand to 18.44 kips (LRFD LC6, 1.2D + E + L + 0.15S), D/C = 0.23.


Two-Way Shear (LRFD)

V2 = qu,avg[Af - (Lp + d)(Bp + d)] = 0.74 ksf × [64 ft² - (1.5 + 1.21)² ft²] = 41.75 kips (LRFD LC1)

bo = 4 × (18 in. + 14.56 in.) = 130.25 in., so the shear stress without moment transfer is vuv = V2/(bod) = 41,750 lb / (130.25 in. × 14.56 in.) = 22.01 psi.

The pedestal also delivers a moment to the top of the footing: Msc = M + VHp = 0 + 1.4 × 0.28 kips × 2 ft = 0.78 kip-ft. Per ACI 318-19 Section 8.4.4.2, the fraction γv = 1 - γf = 1 - 1/(1 + (2/3)√(b1/b2)) = 0.40 of that moment is carried by shear stress on the critical section, with b1 = b2 = 32.56 in., cAB = b1/2 = 16.28 in. and Jc = 352 × 10³ in⁴:

vu = vuv + γvMsccAB/Jc = 22.01 psi + 0.40 × 0.78 kip-ft × 12,000 lb-in./kip-ft × 16.28 in. / (352 × 10³ in⁴) = 22.01 + 0.17 = 22.18 psi


CalcBook show-your-work for two-way shear demand: average bearing 0.74 ksf, V2 = 41.75 kips, vuv = 22.01 psi on bo = 130.25 in., and the moment transfer term with gamma v = 0.4, Msc = 0.78 kip-ft and Jc = 352 x 10^3 in^4, for vu = 22.18 psi.

The pedestal is square (β = 1), and with λs neglected the least of the three ACI 318-19 Table 22.6.5.2 stresses governs:

vc = 4λ√f′c = 4 × 1.0 × √4,000 psi = 252.98 psi, φvn = 0.75 × 252.98 = 189.74 psi, D/C = 22.18 / 189.74 = 0.12


CalcBook show-your-work for two-way shear strength: vc = min(252.98, 379.47, 409.34) = 252.98 psi per ACI 318-19 Table 22.6.5.2, and phi vn = 0.75 x 252.98 = 189.74 psi.

In the downward run, LRFD LC6 (1.2D + E + L + 0.15S) governs: V2 = 50.03 kips and Msc = 8.14 kips × 2 ft = 16.27 kip-ft, so vu = 26.38 + 3.61 = 29.99 psi, D/C = 0.16.


Flexure (LRFD)

As = 8 × 0.60 in² = 4.80 in², which meets the minimums CalcBook checks: 3.11 in² for temperature and shrinkage (0.0018 × 18 in. × 96 in.) and 4.66 in² per ACI 318-19 9.6.1.2.

a = Asfy/(0.85f′cB) = 4.80 in² × 60 ksi / (0.85 × 4 ksi × 96 in.) = 0.88 in. The section is tension controlled (εt = 0.039), so φ = 0.90:

φMn = 0.90 × 4.80 in² × 60 ksi × (14.56 in. - 0.88 in. / 2) / 12 = 305.02 kip-ft


CalcBook show-your-work for footing flexural strength: Mn = 4.8 in^2 x 60 ksi x (14.56 - 0.88/2) in. = 338.91 kip-ft and phi Mn = 305.02 kip-ft.

The moment at the pedestal face is 31.64 kip-ft in the uplift run (LRFD LC1, 1.4D) and 47.60 kip-ft in the downward run (LRFD LC6), so flexure stays at D/C = 0.16 or less.


Controlling Demand/Capacity Ratio

Sliding under seismic uplift governs the footing at D/C = 0.86 (ASD LC10, 0.6D + 0.7E). Every other check is at 0.64 or less.


CalcBook spread footing design summary for the uplift run: sliding 0.86, overturning 0.64, bearing 0.30 and 0.24, flexure 0.10, one-way shear 0.15 and two-way shear 0.12 (22.18 psi against 189.74 psi), all OK.



Conclusion:

Moment frames are a cornerstone of structural engineering, offering versatility and resilience in complex loading scenarios. By carefully considering factors such as geometry, loading, and material properties, engineers can achieve designs that are both safe and efficient. Download a free trial of CalcBook to explore the example problem above in full detail. Whether you're applying it to your own design needs or experimenting with the step-by-step workflow, CalcBook simplifies tedious manual calculations, allowing you to focus on what matters most in your projects.


 
 
bottom of page